James Suckling (JS) — 92/100 · Wine Spectator, 31/03/2005 · Drink 2007+
This is beautiful on the nose with currants, berries and flowers. Full-bodied, with silky tannins and pretty fruit. Needs a bit more fruit on the midpalate to be a classic Margaux, but clearly outstanding. Best after 2007. 12,500 cases made.
Robert Parker (RP) — 93/100 · Wine Advocate, RobertParker.com, 30/04/2005 · Drink 2010-2030
Performing better from bottle than at any time in cask (which of course is the objective of great winemaking, isn't it?), this wine reveals a dense ruby/purple color in a style somewhat reminiscent of the 1988 but with more power, concentration, and volume. It has a beautifully elegant nose of black fruits intermixed with truffle, flower, and oak. The wine is medium to full-bodied, dense, with wo…
Jancis Robinson MW (JR) — 17/20 · JancisRobinson.com, 04/11/2009 · Drink 2010-2017
Sweet and easy and round and digestible. Racy, with a very neat finish.